Skip to main content

Pros vs. Cons of Outsourcing Human Resources: What to Know

Employer shaking hands with a contractor.

In today’s dynamic business landscape, human resources professionals with competing priorities are finding it harder to juggle routine tasks. To find cost-effective solutions that save time and resources, HR departments are trying alternative methods, including outsourcing.

Many organizations offer outsourcing for HR tasks. This method is an attractive option when you need more HR staff to complete administrative tasks at a lower cost. While there are positives to shifting your HR management structure, there are also drawbacks.

This blog will take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of outsourcing HR tasks and consider whether it’s a passing trend. Then, we’ll dive deeper into the strategic implications and factors to consider when making this pivotal decision.


The landscape of HR in the modern enterprise

The HR field spans many areas, including external regulations, professional employer organization services, and marketplace and global trends. The scope of HR responsibilities has widened, from simple personnel management to complex, strategic business operations. As a result, cutting-edge platforms and resource management solutions have emerged to meet growing employee expectations.


3 Pros of outsourced HR: A tempting solution

One of the biggest appeals of outsourcing HR functions is reducing resources spent on administrative tasks. By delegating these priorities, in-house HR teams can concentrate on more crucial, value-adding activities like strategic initiatives. Common tasks HR departments outsource include:

  • benefits administration;
  • payroll processing;
  • onboarding and recruitment;
  • employee relations; and
  • compliance.

The outsourcing trend suggests that the industry recognizes the strategic value of offloading operational duties.


1. Automate to innovate: A case for efficiency

Technology helps create efficiency in modern organizations, including the HR function. By outsourcing HR services, some organizations may be able to access tools and expertise that they don’t have in-house. This can enhance the HR team's efficiency and accuracy while building data-driven processes.

Automating time-consuming tasks eliminates errors and liberates HR personnel to innovate in other areas. This includes talent management, employee engagement and organizational development — all pivotal for business success in a competitive environment.


2. Navigating complexity and sensitivity

Outsourcing provides a layer of separation between the organization and potentially sensitive HR situations. For example, third-party specialists can handle employee relations, dispute resolutions, sensitive conversations and terminations. Their professional detachment from the organization can help shield employees from emotion-driven mishaps — or in extreme situations, legal disputes.


3. Capitalizing on specialized expertise

By outsourcing, companies can lean on other providers to complete tasks requiring specialized knowledge. For example, if an HR team notices that they don’t have anyone with a strong compliance background, it may be beneficial to outsource that work. This could save the team time learning regulations or hiring a specialist. It could also help prevent the team from making errors, which reduces risk and improves compliance. In this case, outsourcing can be a risk management strategy as much as an efficiency play.


3 Cons of outsourcing HR tasks

Despite the benefits, outsourcing HR operations comes with its own set of risks and drawbacks. Among the most noted concerns is relinquishing control over critical business processes. The outsourcing provider may have different priorities or may not mesh well with the company’s culture. This could potentially lead to a misalignment in decision-making and sub-par service.


1. The distance dilemma

Distance is a concern for employers. Specifically, there is potential for a disconnect between the outsourced HR function and the organization. This could manifest in a less responsive or less personalized service for the employer, creating a headwind for retention efforts. The employer could find that working with the outsourced service creates new errors or lengthy workflows. As a result, the HR team may have to check the work of the service.


2. The control conundrum

Outsourcing adds external players to your team. You'll want to figure out ahead of time the best ways to manage and leverage the service you plan to use. Without this preparation, you may find you are uncomfortable fully relying on the outsourced individual or service. Some things to consider:

  • Make sure that the company or individual that you're outsourcing to has the ability to adhere to your organization’s values and policies.
  • Determine how you'll monitor the performance of outsourced tasks, particularly in areas requiring fiduciary prudence and oversight.
  • Decide the amount of control necessary to ensure the success of your outsourced projects and tasks.
  • Identify sufficient checks and balances you need to put in place.


3. The appearance of indifference

In some cases, the organization or employees can see outsourcing as a threat. Some might see this as a company trying to save money (and the possibility of other future cuts). Others may view it as a challenge to a company's culture.

Because change sometimes creates pushback, you need to think about the perception of outsourcing HR services. This way, you can plan messaging or tactics that help focus on the positive aspects of the decision to outsource. Employees' want to work for companies making thoughtful, proactive decisions that value their wants or needs.


Evaluating the balance: Do the advantages outweigh the drawbacks?

The growth of HR outsourcing services shows that companies and professionals continue to see value in this approach. Organizations that want to adopt this practice should think about the services they need. This will allow them to tailor their assessment of what can or should be outsourced.

Organizations should consider the pros, efficiency gains, cost savings and strategic focus. They should likewise think about the cons, potential disconnect, loss of control and misalignment with company culture.


The future of HR and outsourcing: A symbiotic partnership

HR outsourcing is moving toward greater integration and collaboration between in-house and external HR providers. The future might see a more symbiotic relationship, where in-house teams focus on strategic, human-centric activities while external partners manage specialized operational processes. This partnership model embodies the best of both worlds, ensuring that HR remains a dynamic and responsive function in the face of ever-changing business dynamics.

The evolution of HR is inexorably tied to the trends and innovations driving modern enterprise. While the decision to outsource is complex and has potential pitfalls, it also presents an array of solutions to the resource challenges traditional HR models face. As technologies advance and the strategic importance of HR increases, the conversation around outsourcing will continue, with practitioners seeking to fine-tune their approach to suit the unique contours of their organization.

The key to success will be a methodical consideration of the tradeoffs involved, a robust governance structure and a continuous evaluation of the impact on the organization’s most important asset: its people.

If you have any questions, don't hesitate to contact our team of experts. We can help you evaluate your organization's needs, from employee benefits to outsourcing to retirement plans — we got you covered.


TruePlan Benefit and Retirement Advisors is a marketing name of Healthcare Community Securities Corp., member FINRA/SIPC, and an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. Past performance is not indicative or a guarantee of future returns. The information in this piece is not a recommendation to invest nor should it be relied upon as instruction to invest. It is not possible to invest directly in an index. Exposure to an asset class represented by an index may be available through investable instruments based on that index. Please visit our website https://trueplanadvisors.com/legal/indices_disclosures for further explanation and detail surrounding the indices referenced within.


Popular posts from this blog

What is Risk Management? 4 Key Topics to Know

Understanding risk management in retirement programs  Managing a retirement program is complex, with multiple layers of risk. For organizations and their leadership, understanding and mitigating these risks is crucial to ensuring the long-term success and reliability of these programs.   It often leaves human resource professionals, employers and program administrators questioning, "What is risk management, and how can we excel at it?"  This blog post explores the various aspects of risk management in retirement program administration and provides actionable insights to help organizations better manage these risks.  The importance of risk management  Retirement programs are designed to benefit participants and beneficiaries, but they come with their own set of risks. These risks can be broadly categorized into four main topics:  Fees  Administration  Investments  Cybersecurity  Each of these topics requires meticulous attention and ...

Innovative employee retention strategies: 9 fresh ideas

Employee engagement and retention are pivotal in every sector, but they carry even more weight in the not-for-profit space, where resources are often limited. High turnover can be both costly and disruptive, impacting productivity and damaging morale. In an era of workforce evolution, to effectively retain their top talent, organizations must explore innovative employee retention strategies that go beyond conventional methods.  Engaged employees are distinguished by their higher productivity, motivation and loyalty, and they are more likely to stay with a company for the long term. Gallup recently updated its research article, The Benefits of Employee Engagement , finding that "low engagement teams typically endure turnover rates that are 18% to 43% higher than highly engaged teams."  In addition to turnover, disengaged employees negatively impact a company's financial health, with turnover costs averaging six to nine months of the departed employee's salary, accordin...

Executive disability income protection program: C-suite FAQ

Implementing a comprehensive risk management strategy is imperative for C-level executives and senior management at HANYS member hospitals. One critical, but often overlooked component, is the executive disability income protection program. But what exactly is this program and why is it vital for high-income earners?   With increasing interest in executive disability income protection programs from C-suite executives, TruePlan Benefit and Retirement Advisors interviewed Bernard A. Gleeson, Director, Employee Benefit Services on Executive disability income protection programs FAQs.  What is an executive disability income protection program?  An executive disability income protection program (EDIPP) is a specialized form of disability insurance designed to supplement existing group disability plans offered by employers. These individual plans provide additional coverage beyond the typical monthly maximum benefit cap found in traditional employer-based offerings. By ove...